Search blogs  
Browse by category
Commentator - Tracking the gems in the ecosystem
Christo Jacob
Author:Christo Jacob
Associate Editor
Did YouTube founders snatch the idea?
Monday 10th, November 2008
Whenit comes to start a company of your own, there are lot of traumas and troubles,an entrepreneur come across. This is a story of an entrepreneur who envisioned to start youtube between 1998-2004. Herbert Elwood Gilliland III claims thatYouTube’s name and idea were his. This is not the first time someone saying that 'He stole my idea'.

Gilliand too, who is specialized in Security, networking, interface, process consulting,medical devices (and requirements), graphic design, advertising, web design,product development have a story to tell.

Gilliand says, “I invented the YouTube brand and worked at a company where I wasdeveloping a similar product in 1998. I inverted several key elements of theproduct “Synthetic Interview” to create YouTube, and shared this idea with myfriends. I also tried to create a company called YouTube several times between1998-2004, when in November, I talked to Chad Hurley on the phone when he wasstill working at PayPal. I explained the idea behind YouTube, the brand name,and challenged him to start the company since he had close ties to Peter Theil,a well known billionaire venture capitalist. I asked for 1% of the proceeds ofthe sale of the company in exchange for this great idea. Years later, I amstill trying to get Chad to recognize me with fiscal compensation and/or creditfor creating the brand, basic concepts (video uploading, video commenting,agnostic video format, layout of the main video screen, awards and top listings“most watched”, star ratings, viewers, DMCA automation, video and audiofingerprinting).

Aftera phone call with Sergey Brin in August of 2007, several other of my ideasbecame a part of YouTube (thumbs-up and thumbs-down, video annotation). Sincethey seem to depend so much on my ideas to make their billions, why can’t thensee the benefit in enabling me to start my own firm? Why do these “altruistic”billionaires not see the benefit in sharing some of their wealth?”

Evenif YouTube founders Chad Hurley, Steve Chen and Jawed Karim get to know thisstory, I guess they will not be ready to give him the credits. So I would liketo advice the hungry entrepreneurs to be careful when you share your hot ideas.You will not know whether your idea is gold mine or not.



(Source of the story: Tech Crunch)

 
Comments
Comment 1: By suresh kumar on 04th Dec 2008
"People are supposed to work with their bodies and not with their mind and brain". Work is what makes you pant with exhaustion and nothing else. Hence the produce of the intellect is literally "priceless"
suresh

Comment 2: By Das Menon on 17th Nov 2008
Ownership of ideas is always a hot issue. When I visit India, I am always struck by the ease with which any program like photoshop or cad can be loaded to your system by anyone. It is free! they say!

I agree! It is good to respect other's ideas and pay for it.

Post your valuable comment here
Email:      Password:  
Don't have SiliconIndia ID? Sign up      Forgot your Password?  Retrieve

 Latest postings

Why not get used to Virtual Wallet?
Today as the concept of virtualization is being discovered, the entrepreneurs are thinking of every commodity to be virtual. Now the companies are a... more >>
The Right pat on the Right shoulder
Gone are the days when employees were recognized for their outstanding performance with trophies and plaques. The corporates are devising innovative... more >>
Autopsy gets Virtual
Technology is revolutionizing in every field. In the past, we have heard about interesting technologies in healthcare sector, where in a doctor, who... more >>
Wanna have a pickup from Airport?
While the new airport of Bangalore was opened, there was lot of noise being made by all the media picking up the distance as a key negative factor d... more >>
redBus: A Green Signal for your Bus Tickets
It is mobile buzz everywhere! Today there are lot of entrepreneurs, who are innovating in the mobile space with their new applications and technology.... more >>

Editors choice

Options Trading , My Comments
Looks like people are very much interested in learning about Deri... more >>
By
Manish Chauhan
USE IT AS A LEVER TO CUT COSTS
Use IT as a lever to cut costs The global economic slowdown is ... more >>
By
VIRAJ YASHODHAN MAHESHWARI
Is India The Most Racial Country in the World ??
India is the seventh-largest country by geographical area, the se... more >>
By
Vivek Nanda
Top reasons to blog or not to blog
Top Ten Reasons WhyYou Should Blog 10. Because you stopped learn... more >>
By
Sunil Khanduja
Will the earth die on 21 December 2012?
There has been a serious debate going on this subject for quite a... more >>
By
sankar dabendran

Guest contributors

S Ramdorai
S Ramdorai
CEO, TCS
Stephen J Felice
Stephen J Felice
Senior VP and President, Asia-Pacific, Dell
Ravi Thummarukudy
Ravi Thummarukudy
Vice President and General Manager of the IC Solutions Division, GDA Technologies
Vinod Khosla
Vinod Khosla
Founder & CEO, Khosla Ventures.
Jayshree V Ullal
Jayshree V Ullal
Senior Vice President / General Manager, Cisco
 Our sponsors