A Proxy Fight
Sign in

A proxy fight

The recent Jinnah episode has really confused me .I am no fan of Nehru, and definitely not one of Jinnah. I got cured of Nehru’s charm quite sometime back, thanks to a book; a book named Mountbatten and partition of India, possibly written by MB himself. There, the author had un-ashamedly described how he requested his charming wife to tackle Nehru who was extremely disturbed after seeing the partition plan. MB had earlier misled Nehru about the actual borderline of partition.

It said how the partition was proponed to match the 15th August -which was the day of glory for England- as the 2nd world war had ended that day.

But the real cause was Jinnah’s sickness without whom partition would not have materialized. Britons were reconciled to the idea of leaving India politically but not economically. Till today, Pakistan is an open market for western economies.

It is well known that Jinnah, kept his sickness a secret and he was eager for the post. But not many know that Nehru could have prevented it if he was not so hopelessly enamored by Mrs. MB. His intention possibly was not evil but he was naïve enough to play a fool to the scheming British authority.

Of the two leaders, there cannot be any comparison as Nehru cultivated a soft civilized image. On the other hand, Jinnah was the proverbial go getter, who did not shy from a bloodbath to serve his purpose. One was perpetrator, the other a docile spectator.

The raw terror that had followed had made the two nations permanent enemies..

Though it had happened long time ago, my family bleeds from that trauma even today.

There was a time, I used to have vehement hatred for Jinnah as I believed he was the chief architect of partition. But with age my viewpoints have changed. Now I feel, but for partition, the whole of India would have been Pakistan.

Last few years we have seen, sporadic acts of terror. It would have been a way of life, as it is in Pakistan, Iran or Afganistan. I even think may be Jinnah had unintentionally saved us from that possibility.

In ancient times, history used to be written by kings and queens.

In modern times the same is done by leaders. They often write on controversial topics. They have the readership to attract the publishers and controversy sells. So no wonder JS has chosen Jinnah as the protagonist of his book.

The reaction of BJP also seems to be well calculated. BJP is providing JS the best publicity he could ever hope to get. Result is simple, people will read and some will blame Nehru and Congress can't say a single thing against BJP. It can’t say that BJP is trying tarnish its great PM.

The negative publicity to JS will make educated people refresh their memory , read a few old books and some of the charisma of great Nehru will be rubbed off in the process. It is plain politics.

But should the leaders of a national party stoop so low as to attack one of the most sacred principle of Indian democracy ;the freedom of speech. Congress can’t say a thing. Because for electoral popularity, they already had used this weapon. They too have banned books. Survival in the dirty politics make the clean people also dirty. So no wonder BJP is playing same dirty tricks practiced by its opponents.

start_blog_img